Reviews of Safran Troublant by L'Artisan Parfumeur
L'Artisan Parfumeur brought to life a "potent portrait of a candied rose" with Safran Troublant, an elevated and inviting gourmand rose fragrance.
Its candied sweetness peaks in the initial spray, and the scent becomes more nuanced as it settles on the skin. The heat of the skin reveals its dimension - sweet vanilla and sheer rose, harmoniously blended with saffron, ginger, and a subtle cumin aspect. These soft spices and a smooth sandalwood linger deep into the dry down, resulting in a well-balanced, feminine scent with a seductive touch.
Safran Troublant is a perfect representation of perfumer Olivia Giacobetti’s iconic style: evocative, atmospheric, and refined. Its gentle projection creates an intimate, personal aura, making it versatile enough for daily wear, yet classy enough for special occasions.
I have decants of Safran Troublant available, feel free to send me a message if you’re hoping to get your nose on it!
Its candied sweetness peaks in the initial spray, and the scent becomes more nuanced as it settles on the skin. The heat of the skin reveals its dimension - sweet vanilla and sheer rose, harmoniously blended with saffron, ginger, and a subtle cumin aspect. These soft spices and a smooth sandalwood linger deep into the dry down, resulting in a well-balanced, feminine scent with a seductive touch.
Safran Troublant is a perfect representation of perfumer Olivia Giacobetti’s iconic style: evocative, atmospheric, and refined. Its gentle projection creates an intimate, personal aura, making it versatile enough for daily wear, yet classy enough for special occasions.
I have decants of Safran Troublant available, feel free to send me a message if you’re hoping to get your nose on it!
Olivia Giacobetti's compositions are transportive and beguiling. They do not demand your attention. I liken them to ambient music. She could very well be the Brian Eno or Harold Budd of perfumers. The levels are never turned up to 11, and while quiet, her works are by no means weak. After all, returning to the music analogy, is quiet music any less real and valid than propulsive rhythms and loud rock? Evaluating fragrance on whether it is "noticed" is much like evaluating art by the lowest common denominator. "My favorite musician has reached number 1 on Billboard 10 times, and yours barely cracked the top 40." The false corollary follows that the former is inherently superior. Rather daft thinking, in my humble opinion, but all too common.
Safran Troublant opens with saffron realism and at this point I frankly don't care how she did it because I want to get lost in the story. It's that heavenly smell of stigmas, carotenoid-rich threads, macerated at the bottom of mortar by a pestle. There's nothing else like it, and Giacobetti captures it here. It soon smooths over within a vanilla cloud, sprinkled with sugar, doused with rose and underpinned by sandalwood. Simple as that, and simply beautiful it is: a harmony of all elements.
I feel happy that autumn is fast approaching as I wear this. While it makes for a pretty-sounding name, I am not sure why it's called "troublant" as it has quite the opposite effect, it soothes rather than seduces, like a hot cup of tea or a hug from a friend. It's a hug to perfumers from Olivia.
Safran Troublant opens with saffron realism and at this point I frankly don't care how she did it because I want to get lost in the story. It's that heavenly smell of stigmas, carotenoid-rich threads, macerated at the bottom of mortar by a pestle. There's nothing else like it, and Giacobetti captures it here. It soon smooths over within a vanilla cloud, sprinkled with sugar, doused with rose and underpinned by sandalwood. Simple as that, and simply beautiful it is: a harmony of all elements.
I feel happy that autumn is fast approaching as I wear this. While it makes for a pretty-sounding name, I am not sure why it's called "troublant" as it has quite the opposite effect, it soothes rather than seduces, like a hot cup of tea or a hug from a friend. It's a hug to perfumers from Olivia.
ADVERTISEMENT
Safran Troublant by L'Artisan Parfumeur (2002) is really for vanilla lovers, despite what the name may otherwise suggest. Composed by the online fragrance community favorite Olivia Giacobetti, this L'Artisan scent is marketed towards women, but is really a good fit for any vanilla fan that doesn't mind crossing swords with a bit of saffron and rose. Safran Troublant could be called an oriental fragrance, and it does indeed have a pasty sort of indolic musk and sandalwood edge which reminds me of any number of Indian or Arabian-market oils; but if you insist on using that nomenclature, remember that it isn't the Western or ostensibly occidental interpretation of "oriental", and rather actually modeled after something that could be found in the middle or far east. That said, this isn't terribly animalic or challenging either as you might expect that description to make it, because vanilla is the dominant factor here once the dry down happens, and there is nothing challenging about that outside maybe the thick way it's presented by Giacobetti. Yeah, there is noticeable saffron coming and going enough to justify the name, even if perhaps something like "Safran Vanille" may have been a better title for the perfume. Giacobetti seems to have some of her greatest works discontinued like Penhaligon's Elixir (2009), but this one fortunately endures.
The opening of Safran Troublant is a blast of ginger, passion flower, and some white floral notes that uplift the core of rose, jasmine indole, and saffron. In some ways, this reminds me of a cross between Jasmin Impératrice Eugénie by Creed (1870) and Lust by Gorilla Perfume (2010) in these moments. Eventually, the floral and spiced opening give way to a creamy vanilla and sandalwood, held together by some musk and a bit of tonka. Some sites list a sugar note here, and I guess the sweetness could in and of itself be seen as a separate note, although I find it's just a symptom of other ingredients combined. Indole, vanilla, sandalwood, and traces of the florals becomes the final character of Safran Troublant, and wear time is considerably long. Safran Troublant is creamy, and just borders on the edge of cloying without crossing over the line. Projection and sillage are really good too, but with so many strong ingredients, you could almost expect that. Best use for this would be fall or winter time for me, somewhere cozy and relaxed. I don't see Safran Troublant as a particularly extroverted people-pleasing fragrance, no matter who wears it, and I don't see it working well in sticky heat or humidity. Naturally, vanilla can be seen as cloying to some, and is a particularly sweet, musky take on the note, so be warned. This stuff is the chamomile tea of vanilla fragrances.
L'Artisan Parfumeur has gone through a terrible shake-up since this stuff launched, with a great many of their more noteworthy and talked-about fragrances being discontinued in favor of more insipid watery floral dreck that the corporate bean counters think will bring in the nouveau-riche money that tends to keep niche brands like this a float these days. Scents like Dzing! (1999) and the previous Giacobetti-penned Tea for Two (2000) have been put out to pasture in favor of more uninspired Western oud takes and woody-amber things that are only a peg or two above what designers offer, but that's what pays the bills in today's "of rich and poor" society obsessed with fast-fashion. Safran Troublant alongside Al Oudh (2009), L'Eau d'Ambre (1978), Mûre et Musc (1978), L'Eau du Caporal (1985), Voluer de Roses (1993), Premier Figuer (1994), Méchant Loup (1997), and the immortal Timbuktu (2004) remain to remind some of what L'Artisan once was, but for how long? This used to be the counter-culture perfume house numero uno, now it's the bean counter house numero zero. Jean Laporte must rolling in his grave. My sample came from an older gold-capped bottle, so I don't know the state of newer black caps, although jasmine, rose, and sandalwood are all expensive materials that a shyster could cheap out on in reformulation. Thumbs up
The opening of Safran Troublant is a blast of ginger, passion flower, and some white floral notes that uplift the core of rose, jasmine indole, and saffron. In some ways, this reminds me of a cross between Jasmin Impératrice Eugénie by Creed (1870) and Lust by Gorilla Perfume (2010) in these moments. Eventually, the floral and spiced opening give way to a creamy vanilla and sandalwood, held together by some musk and a bit of tonka. Some sites list a sugar note here, and I guess the sweetness could in and of itself be seen as a separate note, although I find it's just a symptom of other ingredients combined. Indole, vanilla, sandalwood, and traces of the florals becomes the final character of Safran Troublant, and wear time is considerably long. Safran Troublant is creamy, and just borders on the edge of cloying without crossing over the line. Projection and sillage are really good too, but with so many strong ingredients, you could almost expect that. Best use for this would be fall or winter time for me, somewhere cozy and relaxed. I don't see Safran Troublant as a particularly extroverted people-pleasing fragrance, no matter who wears it, and I don't see it working well in sticky heat or humidity. Naturally, vanilla can be seen as cloying to some, and is a particularly sweet, musky take on the note, so be warned. This stuff is the chamomile tea of vanilla fragrances.
L'Artisan Parfumeur has gone through a terrible shake-up since this stuff launched, with a great many of their more noteworthy and talked-about fragrances being discontinued in favor of more insipid watery floral dreck that the corporate bean counters think will bring in the nouveau-riche money that tends to keep niche brands like this a float these days. Scents like Dzing! (1999) and the previous Giacobetti-penned Tea for Two (2000) have been put out to pasture in favor of more uninspired Western oud takes and woody-amber things that are only a peg or two above what designers offer, but that's what pays the bills in today's "of rich and poor" society obsessed with fast-fashion. Safran Troublant alongside Al Oudh (2009), L'Eau d'Ambre (1978), Mûre et Musc (1978), L'Eau du Caporal (1985), Voluer de Roses (1993), Premier Figuer (1994), Méchant Loup (1997), and the immortal Timbuktu (2004) remain to remind some of what L'Artisan once was, but for how long? This used to be the counter-culture perfume house numero uno, now it's the bean counter house numero zero. Jean Laporte must rolling in his grave. My sample came from an older gold-capped bottle, so I don't know the state of newer black caps, although jasmine, rose, and sandalwood are all expensive materials that a shyster could cheap out on in reformulation. Thumbs up
Roses and saffron ? yes, for only for a few minutes. What you get after that is vanilla, sweet vanilla, and it lasts unfortunately: I had to wash my wardrobe the day after because the lingering smell was too strong and made me sick. Where have the roses and the saffron gone ?!
Delicate ? No. Elegant ? No. Sexy ? Is smelling like a vanilla rice pudding sexy ?
To me it's just plain chemical vanilla. I'm fine with the vanilla of Shalimar, but this is way too much on the foody/gourmand side.
Delicate ? No. Elegant ? No. Sexy ? Is smelling like a vanilla rice pudding sexy ?
To me it's just plain chemical vanilla. I'm fine with the vanilla of Shalimar, but this is way too much on the foody/gourmand side.
Beautifully blended. Perfect, actually. Just the right amount of each note creates a powdered rose, tiniest spice, non-overbearing vanilla, and calming amounts of sandalwood potion. One of the prettiest Rose fragrances out there. I recommend trying, if you enjoy feminine, nearly "lipstick"-style, rose perfumes...
A little more vanilla appears later on.
A little more vanilla appears later on.
Easy and gentle. The rose mingles nicely with the saffron and smells almost muggy in a way. Slightly spicy here and there and I get notes of holiday incense floating here and there, more like a whiffs of a specialty bakery. Very straightforward vanilla accents flit in and out.
I like this. The saffron note is soft and round, and the whole thing has a nice, delicious balance, with rose and vanilla. The perfumer, Olivia Giacobetti, did a nice job.
This is kind of thing I would feel confident wearing anywhere or recommending to anyone, a safe, likable, lovely fragrance that smells competently made (not edgy, quirky, or clumsy).
This is kind of thing I would feel confident wearing anywhere or recommending to anyone, a safe, likable, lovely fragrance that smells competently made (not edgy, quirky, or clumsy).
Chalked with vanilla,
This rose in saffron's name is
Disturbingly hot.
This rose in saffron's name is
Disturbingly hot.
Yes Safran Troublant is a comforting lovely work of delicate spicy alchemy by Olivia Giacobetti and another ideal jump in a dreamy universe of adolescent flashbacks, fairy tales, rosey gracious delicacy and fuzzy soporific projections. Olden Christmas-holidays' flashbacks jump serenely on mind (from the abysses of your childhood) with their background of cakes, sweets and caresses. Saffron is like an hook for sweet left back far memories of disappeared ages. Rose and saffron are well modulated in a light and fresh way, ending to be finally encompassed by a soft kiss of warm yummy (kind of nutty) vanilla. Overall the alchemy is poetic and soft. Not my ideal kind of work. Faint structure (unlike the most part of Giacobetti's renditions). An atmosphere (yes artistically rendered) more than a veritable structured fragrance in motion.
I love this scent. It's a custardy rice pudding made with jasmine rice, rosewater, and a generous helping of saffron, creamy and redolent of sweet spices. It is a fine confection, with just enough suggestion of sensuality to give it an edge.
Alas, it is as ephemeral and fleeting as the scent in the kitchen after one has made dessert. It just doesn't last near long enough. Full disclosure, though: "long enough" when something smells this lovely would be "lasts for days on end." But still, it disappears in a matter of a couple of hours. Safran Troublant is a heartbreaker of a scent.
Alas, it is as ephemeral and fleeting as the scent in the kitchen after one has made dessert. It just doesn't last near long enough. Full disclosure, though: "long enough" when something smells this lovely would be "lasts for days on end." But still, it disappears in a matter of a couple of hours. Safran Troublant is a heartbreaker of a scent.
Safran Troublant opens with an extremely realistic smell of saffron, and I mean the actual ground saffron you can buy at the drugstore, just lightly enhanced by rose and vanilla, both blending with the floral and sweeter sides of saffron. The whole, quite simple ensemble is topped with a nose-tingling spicy note resembling to cumin, a slightly cheaper hint of eugenol (cloves, basically) and an odd, almost random touch that reminds me of a sort of a damp lemongrass-infused tampon - it may sound bizarre, but it works. I think it's due to rose. Anyway that's it, a graceful and quite refined blend of thin spices and gentle powdery-sweet accents, with a fascinating sort of subtle, almost transparent texture revolving around the edible heart of saffron. And well, a couple of cheap nuances, but tolerably covered by the good parts. The notes may make it seem a thick Oriental bomb, while on the contrary it has more of a British presence diaphanous and discreet, with a sophisticated sort of camphorous, musky, earthy yet smooth cashmere-suede feel (I think due to saffron) that adds some further elegance to this mannered blend, slightly reminding me of Hermès Cuir d'Ange. I admit this fragrance is fairly pleasant to wear, at least for the first phases of its evolution, but there's a gigantic flaw I can't avoid to mention and which sadly, makes Safran Troublant look like (as so many - too many niche scents) a half-baked work: the longevity, which is unacceptably short and really subtle for my tastes. Way too much. Within 20-30 minutes, you already remain with the faint, nondescript drydown it should have after 5 or 6 hours. A time machine in a bottle. Still, one of L'Artisan Parfumeur's scents I enjoyed the most.
6,5/10
6,5/10
This is delicious; a Perfumery equivalent of a Custard Tart but with Clove rather than Nutmeg. It opens soft and Vanilla sweet. Gradually Clove appears; the whole is beautifully blended. There may be some Saffron there but if there is I can hardly detect it. Judging by the colour of the fragrance, if there is some Saffron it is just a smidgeon, or a colourless variety was used.
Wish it lasted longer, but I'm happy with the strength. All in all a "thumbs up".
Wish it lasted longer, but I'm happy with the strength. All in all a "thumbs up".
A light (and I do mean light) saffron with light spices and vanilla. Nothing complicated (not a bad thing).A light (and i do mean light)rose note sneaks in there in a few minutes. Caution: The projection and longevity on ST is very weak. A great smelling fragrance nonetheless.
Olivia Giacobetti has a way of combining disparate elements to make something that while surprising is never shocking. Unexpected, but perfectly coherent when you think about it. The sweet and salty hay of Dzing! The smoked-lily soap of Passage d'Enfer.
It's a delicious way of changing our reality. The trick is neither fantastical nor over-the-top. She gives us something that doesn't really exist, but easily could since it makes perfect sense. In Safran Troublant, she doesn't give us a talking bear or a winged horse. She gives us a rose/saffron marshmallow. Not only is this imaginable, it starts to convinces me that I might actually have eaten one of these marshmallow at some time or other. The perfume is so persuasive that I question myself. Is the perfume a memory or an imagination? Giacobetti speculates so effectively that I question the experience, but she does it so deftly that ultimately I don't care. It's as if I'm day-dreaming. My mind eases a bit and I become more mindful and less perplexed.
Some perfumes call to mind comparisons to the visual arts. The portraiture of the soliflor. The fruity-floral as a still-life image. The abstract expressionism of Timbuktu. Giacobetti breaks into the written word with her perfume. Safran Troublant is literary fiction. It is the perfect short story. I don't know of any other perfumer who does this.
from scenthurdle.com
It's a delicious way of changing our reality. The trick is neither fantastical nor over-the-top. She gives us something that doesn't really exist, but easily could since it makes perfect sense. In Safran Troublant, she doesn't give us a talking bear or a winged horse. She gives us a rose/saffron marshmallow. Not only is this imaginable, it starts to convinces me that I might actually have eaten one of these marshmallow at some time or other. The perfume is so persuasive that I question myself. Is the perfume a memory or an imagination? Giacobetti speculates so effectively that I question the experience, but she does it so deftly that ultimately I don't care. It's as if I'm day-dreaming. My mind eases a bit and I become more mindful and less perplexed.
Some perfumes call to mind comparisons to the visual arts. The portraiture of the soliflor. The fruity-floral as a still-life image. The abstract expressionism of Timbuktu. Giacobetti breaks into the written word with her perfume. Safran Troublant is literary fiction. It is the perfect short story. I don't know of any other perfumer who does this.
from scenthurdle.com
I love the creamy initial blast of saffron and rose, but the rose soon leaves and I am left with a medicinal clove-like after scent of the saffron and a bland vanilla.
Very light and not very long lasting.
A for originality, D for follow-through.
Very light and not very long lasting.
A for originality, D for follow-through.
I could have sworn there was cardamom in this - like Cartier Declaration but better and more gourmand. In any case, it's wonderful and after one sniff I was hooked. I'm very much looking forward to sniff number two.
Veritas and Proportion are the guiding deities behind this divine scent. Giacobetti propitiates Veritas by realizing the truest saffron note I have yet encountered in perfumery this is the real thing, the kind of magical intoxicating fragrance that first made people pick crocus stamens in back-breaking labour. Unadulterated saffron is pretty difficult to source these days and thus many people's perception of this note can be a bit mixed up.
Proportion (and no doubt craft) is what makes one baker turn out a minor miracle with flour, water, yeast and salt, and another a chewy lump. Here the merest dab of rose gives extra propulsion to the saffron at the start, and then the vanilla smoothes and gently warms the entire composition into creamy voluptuousness. To call this a gourmand is to somewhat miss the point; to my mind this has the erotic charge of being with someone with whom one is completely at ease and to whom surrender will bring only pleasure.
Sadly, loses strength fast and needs reapplications.
Proportion (and no doubt craft) is what makes one baker turn out a minor miracle with flour, water, yeast and salt, and another a chewy lump. Here the merest dab of rose gives extra propulsion to the saffron at the start, and then the vanilla smoothes and gently warms the entire composition into creamy voluptuousness. To call this a gourmand is to somewhat miss the point; to my mind this has the erotic charge of being with someone with whom one is completely at ease and to whom surrender will bring only pleasure.
Sadly, loses strength fast and needs reapplications.
As you may have gathered by now, you're buying this for the first 30 minutes or so, which are pure comfort-scent wonderfulness. This makes it a top rate fragrance for before-bed application.
I don't go through too many bottles, but I'm on my second of this one, because I use it so much this way.
I don't go through too many bottles, but I'm on my second of this one, because I use it so much this way.
I agree with the flavors on the previous posts. Not a sexy scent to me, like Opium, but a comforting scent.
To me this one smells like oldfashioned rosewater...cheap, thin, quiet and inoffensive, but nothing to wear nowadays.
This is my story. I walked into Barney's on Madison Avenue, I told the SA I was looking for a nice vanilla, she handed me this first. I smelled it. I bought it, and I left.
I've never smelled anything remotely similar. If you like vanilla/saffron perfection, you have come to the right place. Get this one.
I've never smelled anything remotely similar. If you like vanilla/saffron perfection, you have come to the right place. Get this one.
I had tried a sample of Safran Troublant a while back and found it quite intriguing, very different from many of the more floral L'Artisan fragrances I've tested. Finding a whole bottle at a decent price, though, wasn't the easiest task, but I finally managed to get a partial bottle from a swap site.Yesterday was my first public wearing of the scent. I knew I had an exacting day ahead of me--an appointment with my therapist (because one always feels a bit "troublant") plus as many errands as I could fit in before the anticipated thunderstorms. Although my experience has been that many L'Artisan fragrances are quite short on sillage and longevity, Safran Troublant nevertheless outlasted my own energy, and it was still going strong when I collapsed into an early bed last night.On me, Safran Troublant is a heady, voluptuous spicy oriental. Saffron, I find, is the most prominent note, surrounded by a rich and harmonious blend of passion flower, rose, and vanilla. Every now and then I got a whiff of sandalwood emerging from under my clothing when I moved suddenly. All in all, I was surrounded by a luxuriously pleasant but unobtrusive aura of fragrance for over eight hours.The scent developed very little over time--but when something is this lovely, who wants it to change?
I finally got a full bottle of this wonderful scent
and I am sooo pleased with it.
Its my first venture into the
Gourmand category of fragrances.
I love this smooth, sensuously
light and spicy scent.
The Saffron infusion ...added to
a rich and unique mixture of flower notes and my favorite base ... Vanilla!!!!
although it may sound like a "Plate of Paella"...
its very .... Uni-Sex in my book...
I cant stop smelling my wrist ....
and can't wait to wear this out and see what the response is from friends and strangers.
UP Date Oct7 2010:
My only compliant:
Non lasting and fleeting!
I find myself spraying it over and over....
to recapture its ethereal
magic.
and I am sooo pleased with it.
Its my first venture into the
Gourmand category of fragrances.
I love this smooth, sensuously
light and spicy scent.
The Saffron infusion ...added to
a rich and unique mixture of flower notes and my favorite base ... Vanilla!!!!
although it may sound like a "Plate of Paella"...
its very .... Uni-Sex in my book...
I cant stop smelling my wrist ....
and can't wait to wear this out and see what the response is from friends and strangers.
UP Date Oct7 2010:
My only compliant:
Non lasting and fleeting!
I find myself spraying it over and over....
to recapture its ethereal
magic.